1964: Malcolm X gives a speech in which he claims that, since he is a black man in America, he cannot even consider himself an American based on how he is treated.
2008: A mere forty-four years later, a black man is elected as President of the United States.
Barack Obama Victory Speech, Grant Park, Chicago
November 2008
We all remember where we were on November 4th, 2008, when Barack Obama made history as the first black man ever elected to be President of the United States. I remember watching the election results with my family at home, elated at the fact that we had witnessed history and proud of how far our country had come. I stayed up to watch the speech, and was so moved by its theme of America's ability to change, told through the life of 106-year-old Ann Nixon Cooper, a lady who had lived through all of America's hardships and heartache, maintaining a hope and knowledge that things could change that allowed her to vote on a touch screen for the first black man as president. This theme is achieved by a reliance on allusion to past American history and reference to leaders who had come before us to enact change. Even in times where it seemed as if Uncle Sam would remain corrupted, as he was throughout the 1960s Civil Rights Movement according to Malcolm X, and that America would not find its way out of darkness, it proved time and time again that it could. As Obama famously said, "That's the true genius of America, that America can change. Our union can be perfected."
And after reading Malcolm X's "The Ballot or the Bullet" speech, I was able to fully understand this "true genius of America" Obama referred to on that brisk Autumn night. Reading the speech, I was outraged, outraged at how mistreated and misrepresented blacks at the time were by those in the government and Congress who claimed they would help them. I was hurt, hurt by how I too agreed with Malcolm X's opinion that Uncle Sam, a seemingly innocent and patriotic figure, had blood on his hands, that he wasn't offering an American dream, but an American nightmare. But most of all, I was inspired. Inspired by the strength Malcolm X possessed; that even in the face of so much adversity and so much disappointment, he kept the hope that America could one day be a nation that accepted all races. He, just as the first black man elected president said forty years later, even in times that he was told he couldn't, "pressed on with that American creed: 'Yes we can.'"
![]() |
| Barack Obama's "Yes we can" slogan refers to the constant efforts of leaders who have come before, such as Malcolm X. Found here. |
Malcolm X argued for the urgent need to bring about change -- that it was 1964; no one could wait any longer for change. He argued for this change through the use of the ballot or the bullet. The ballot, he said, was the most effective ways of bringing about freedom. Voting, and voicing one's opinion, are the most important means of participating in a democracy, something that Malcolm X introduced and something that we as citizens must all remember. Because of the ballot, our freedom to vote and say what we want to say, Malcolm X reminded his followers that they could change history. And they did.
It is these people that Obama refers to when he credits the beauty of America: it is the people who stand up for what is right, who do not give up in face of adversity, and who recognize that if they rely on the ballot, and their own determination to enact change, our country can and will move forward.
The 1960's was one of our country's darkest decades, in which basic human (as Malcolm X calls them) rights were denied and people were killed just for the color of their skin. Even in these darkest of days, Malcolm X and others like him found the strength to stand up and fight for what they knew to be right, using their words to inspire others to join them and using the ballot to enact change. The genius of America is this: people recognize the ability of our country to change, and, despite adversity, they act on it, just as Malcolm X did. With the ballot, the basic American freedom that allows us all to have a voice, we all must recognize this fact that we all have the ability to change something, maybe even the world.
Reading Malcolm X's speech was eyeopening in so many regards. That November night when Barack Obama was elected, I obviously recognized the significance of his being elected, as well as the history that was made. But, I can say that after reading Malcolm X's speech, I now understand and appreciate so much better the beauty of our country. Only a mere forty-four years after a black man claimed, with just reason, that he did not even consider himself an American, a black man sits in the Oval Office as our commander-in-chief.

I have one small point of contention, specifically with your statement that Malcolm X "kept the hope that America could one day be a nation that accepted all races". From what I learned in AP US History, Malcolm X was a prominent member of the Nation of Islam and, in accordance with its doctrine, advocated blacks to separate from white America. I know toward the end of his life he left the Nation of Islam, but I’m not sure if he changed his views. Regardless, Malcolm X did not always think America would one day accept all races. I think MLK fits this notion better, considering he supported the peaceful integration of all races. MLK would not have supported this unless he believed it could be accomplished.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteYour post is pretty uplifting. "After forty-four years... a black man sits in the oval office" was a nice way of ending the post. But I believe, like Jackson above, that Malcolm X wasn't as important as MLK in this process. By Malcolm X preaching the ballot or the bullet, he hurt MLK's campaign of non-violent protests. Malcolm X sought out to fight against the government for equality, unlike MLK who wanted to work with them to correct injustice. I think it is MLK's ideology that created a path for the first Black President as the violence that Malcolm X preached seemed to only cause a further divide between races.
ReplyDeleteI think both MLK and Malcolm X are important civil rights leaders as they both stressed the need to change segregation. But I think the more important and crucial role that facilitated the change was played by MLK.
Joseph,
DeleteI don't agree with you completely. Yes, MLK has a connotation as making a bigger impact on the Civil Rights movement because in today's society, we appreciate his non-violent tactics over Malcolm X's violent tendencies. However, I think the reason why I appreciate the Ballot or the Bullet so much is because it reveals a different side of Malcolm X than history books typically choose to embody in descriptions of him. Don't get me wrong, I generally approve of MLK's tactics over Malcolm X's. But the ballot or the bullet demonstrates how Malcolm X was resorting to violence because the system of government was not functioning in the way it was intended to. While I condemn the violence, and also think of it as a less effective tactic than MLK's, I can understand through his rational, calm reasoning why violence seemed like the only place to turn.
So, I don't think we can say who played a more important role in the movement. I, for one, would like to see both activists and their writings presented in our history books for many years to come.
I like your look at the "Yes We Can". I've heard so much criticism through things like "No We Can't, not with you as president" and "Depression? Yes we can!"
ReplyDeleteBut his slogan reaches a little bit deeper. I like this whole post. It's so touching to see how far America has come, and with rights on the rise for gays and other groups around the world, we certainly can. Maybe one man can't fix the economy, but he's a huge stepping stone in the advancement of American tolerance and increased world tolerance. Very well said.